Cincinnatus Announces Its Position on Key Ballot Measures
With early voting about to begin and Election Day fast approaching, the Cincinnatus Association has taken a position on three measures that Ohio voters will see on the general election ballot.
“Our members have tried to evaluate each of these measures, weighing the pros and cons, in order to decide our position on each one. Elective office races on this year’s ballot are dominant in television ads, especially the races for governor and the U.S. Senate. But these three ballot measures are particularly consequential for our community and state,” Cincinnatus Association President Alice Schneider said.
“The most important message to citizens is to vote, whether early or on Election Day. We hope our positions and our reasoning will guide voters in deciding what to favor and what to oppose this year.
“We oppose Issue 3, a proposed constitutional amendment involving voter identification requirements. We see it as unnecessary since existing law adequately protects election integrity in Ohio. We endorse and urge strong voter support of Issue 4, the Cincinnati Public School levy, and Issue 11, the children’s services levy. Both provide needed public support for the needs of our community’s young people.”
Here are our positions and our reasoning:
Ohio Voter ID Constitutional Amendment (Issue 3)
We oppose the constitutional amendment establishing voter identification requirements because such specific requirements are best handled by statute rather than by constitutional language. Under existing statutes, Ohio is widely considered among the states with the strictest voter ID statutes. Ohio is one of ten states with a strict photo ID requirement to vote (source: National Conference of State Legislatures).
Two key reasons for our position:
- This ballot issue is confusing to all voters as the outcome of the vote will not change anything for Ohio voters who already have safe, secure, and stable elections. Whether the ballot initiative passes or fails, the existing voter ID laws will still be the election laws of the state.
- Existing laws have proven strong in assuring election integrity while maintaining the flexibility to revise those protections if future circumstances (e.g., new technologies) were to warrant it. For example, future technologies such as biometric identification could become commonplace. Today in Ohio you can use your digital wallet to fly but not to vote. This amendment could lock out future technology that promises to be both more secure and more available.
Cincinnati Public Schools Levy (Issue 4)
We recognize the demonstrated need to address funding gaps caused by major cuts in state and federal funding and the challenge of forecasting amount of funding from these sources. This endorsement recognizes a strategic plan that addresses ways to improve academic achievement and reduce chronic absenteeism and provides strong measures for monitoring progress funding.
Two key reasons for our position:
- CPS has not had a levy solely for operating expenses since 2014. Without the new money, CPS will face a negative cash balance by 2029, if not before, despite cuts CPS has already made in the budget.
- The levy is necessary to make up for the cuts in state and federal funding. And CPS and other Ohio school districts have difficulty forecasting the amount of state and federal funding going forward.
Children’s Services Levy (Issue 10)
We recognize both the demonstrated need to maintain essential services for abused and neglected children and the need for continued fiscal discipline, transparency, accountability, and rigorous oversight of services delivered, including foster care placements and in-home supports, throughout the next levy cycle. These significant needs don’t go away even if funding does. Hence, funding is crucial.
Further, we urge the State of Ohio to increase its financial responsibility for mandated child welfare services and reduce the disproportionate reliance on local property taxes to protect children who are suffering from or at risk of abuse or neglect.
Two key reasons for our position:
- The proposed levy is a compromise, not the full amount recommended by the independent review process. The Tax Levy Review Committee recommended approximately $144 million in annual levy revenue. Commissioners instead placed a $116 million proposal before voters after weighing the demonstrated financial need against the additional burden on property taxpayers.
- The county already has begun making difficult reductions rather than relying solely on taxpayers to close the gap. JFS has reduced or shifted spending, including cuts to prevention and other non-mandated services. The proposed levy therefore comes after cost-cutting efforts and would still require continued spending restraint, additional revenue sources and close oversight during the next four years.


